Oprah and her religious beliefs feelings

  • Remem­ber the bad feel­ing I got back HERE about Oprah’s planned Web­casts? Well, she’s done a cou­ple of them now, and my bad feel­ing has become a down­right awful feel­ing.

    I knew that she wanted to do these Web­casts so that she could reach and teach a large audi­ence about a book she loved called “A New Earth.” I kind of fig­ured that this wasn’t going to be excerpts from St. Basil the Great or any­thing, but I didn’t know she was going to go off into the real tinfoil-hat-wearing stuff.

    And that’s where she’s gone, judg­ing from this YouTube video with excerpts from the Web­casts. It starts off with a lit­tle back­ground from Oprah’s show that demon­strates that she was already an adher­ent of the New Age-y baloney-speak that there are mil­lions of paths to God. She even says that it’s impos­si­ble that there would be just one way. I think it’s pretty darn pre­cious that she gets push­back on that from her own audi­ence:
    Woman: What about Jesus?
    Oprah: What about Jesus?
    Woman: There is one way and only one way, and that is through Jesus. (scat­tered applause)

    Uh oh. Dis­sent in the ranks. Time to cut to a commercial.

    But that part wasn’t as piti­ful as the seg­ment of the Web­cast where a woman asked Oprah how she has rec­on­ciled the spir­i­tu­al­ist teach­ings from “A New World” with her Chris­t­ian beliefs. (What Chris­t­ian beliefs? Well, never mind.) Oprah’s answer really amounts to a kind of “anti-witness” — a nar­ra­tive of one person’s apos­tasy. She tells about being in the Bap­tist church in her late 20′s, hear­ing a min­is­ter say that God is a jeal­ous God and how that didn’t “feel right in my spirit.” (Did she know that that pas­sage isn’t just one pastor’s opin­ion, that it’s what God said about Him­self in Exo­dus? I couldn’t tell.) She sat there in church and thought “God is jeal­ous of ME?” Wow, how nar­cis­sis­tic can you get?

    But if Oprah found an orig­i­nal pas­sage to stum­ble over, she is a text­book case of how to fall away altogether:

    1. Get a mis­taken notion about one verse, get a “bad vibe” about how tough Chris­tian­ity is or how mean or how uncool. Allow your­self to get ter­ri­bly offended.
    2. Make sure you don’t talk to any­one who could actu­ally set you straight. That’ll enable you to get to …
    3. Think it over all by your­self and decide that if there is a God, He surely means you to under­stand every­thing about Him and be com­fort­able at all times. So obvi­ously you have to …
    4. Leave your faith, and feel wise and self-righteous about it in order to …
    5. Come up with a whole lot of very strange, implau­si­ble and unrea­son­able ideas and believe them completely

    And what does Oprah believe? Well, you can’t say exactly, because she says that …

    God in the essence of all con­scious­ness isn’t some­thing to believe — God is. God is. And God is a feel­ing expe­ri­ence, not a believ­ing expe­ri­ence. And if your reli­gion is a believ­ing expe­ri­ence, if God for you is still about a belief, then it’s not truly God.

    Not a believ­ing expe­ri­ence, a feel­ing expe­ri­ence. Right.

    Well, I hope a lot of peo­ple are going to feel like she leaves a lot to be desired as a spir­i­tual instruc­tor. She should stick to talk­ing to movie stars. At least when she inter­views Tom Cruise, he’s the one that seems like the weirdo.


    Related posts:

    1. Oprah’s new exer­cise: backpedaling
    2. “Pas­tor with 666 tat­too claims to be divine”
    3. New world count­down: 10, 9, 8 …
    4. Now play­ing at a denom­i­na­tion near you
    5. Con­ser­vatism and morality

16 Responses and Counting...

  • Mimi 04.06.2008

    Yeah, I am not sur­prised either.

  • My wife showed me this video yes­ter­day — I was blown away that peo­ple are buy­ing in to this. My wife said over 500,000 peo­ple signed up for Oprah’s web­cast. When then sat down to eat din­ner and she asked me to pray. I said “I don’t know, I don’t really “feel” God right now — He must not be there.” But, I took a leap of faith and prayed any­way, because, some­how, I’m not sure how, God is beyond my feel­ings, (What?, Wha…no, really? God is that big?)

    As we talked about this video I said, “You know, God is jeal­ous because He knows all other gods are false, and it is you that will be hurt and dis­ap­pointed if you fol­low them, not God.” But, yeah, Oprah’s per­spec­tive was cer­tainly twisted.

  • s-p

    I’d tend to take a more com­pas­sion­ate view. What Oprah is reject­ing is protes­tant Chris­tian­ity, but sees no alter­na­tive except self directed mys­ti­cism. She actu­ally touches the hem of the gar­ment that God IS indeed the source of all con­cious­ness and He is not merely an intel­lec­tual con­struct but ulti­mately to be expe­ri­enced. That’s Ortho­dox. Its too bad the Church didn’t get a hold of her in her twen­ties, she might be Greek by now. :)

  • Nicode­mus:
    Yep, def­i­nitely can’t start to pray until you get the God-feeling. It reminds me that the Amer­i­can Sign Lan­guage sign for Quaker is twid­dling thumbs. Why? Because Quak­ers have to sit there and wait until some­one feels moved in the spirit to begin preaching.

    See? You learn some­thing every day.

  • s-p:
    I don’t know. She cer­tainly is try­ing to avoid error in one direc­tion, but I wish she didn’t have so much influ­ence over so many peo­ple. Because there seems like a lot less chance to me that any­one would get from this “New Earth” par­a­digm to Ortho­doxy Chris­tian­ity, or even (lower-case-o) ortho­dox Christianity.

    Because with all its faults, Protes­tantism does at least say that Jesus Christ is Lord and God, that He is our Sav­ior, etc. etc. So aren’t they at least on the same play­ing field? Oprah and this author def­i­nitely refute that Christ is the only way to God — I don’t know whether they give Him any sin­gu­lar atten­tion, except maybe as the “good teacher” type of thing that C. S. Lewis refuted so well.

  • Ok, so now I’m curi­ous, Grace — what is the ASL sign for Ortho­dox? Do you know?

  • Mimi:
    Had to Google it, but HERE YOU GO.

    Mind you, I don’t know if that’s nec­es­sar­ily Ortho­dox Chris­t­ian, but you could prob­a­bly com­bine the sign.

    Not that I expect to ever need this infor­ma­tion, but you never know.

  • Cool! Thanks!

  • s-p

    Good thoughts, Grace. I guess I often see peo­ple who reject the “pen sub” angry God who kills Jesus instead of us and turn to new age “all you need is love” and won­der which is really worse? Appeas­ing the vol­cano pagan deity or feel­ing good about your god­ness? Its true they acknowl­edge Jesus, but how “real” is the Jesus they acknowl­edge? I dunno. In my mind its degrees not black and white. I guess Idon’t worry so much about her influ­ence, she’s just tick­ling people’s ears… if you’re not in the mar­ket for it you won’t buy it and she’d go out of busi­ness. KnowwhutImean,Vern?

  • I *think* so. I con­fess, I don’t under­stand the “pen sub” ref­er­ence. And I’m hav­ing to guess a lot about the the­o­log­i­cal con­struct of the non-Orthodox I know. I didn’t know so many were fully involved in a juridi­cal under­stand­ing of sal­va­tion — I thought they just wanted to con­sider that God had stamped a big smi­ley face over every­thing and they didn’t have to think about *any­thing* *ever*. Maybe I just don’t know enough non-Orthodox religious-thinker types. Or any, now that I think of it.

    It seems to me that most peo­ple I meet — reli­gious and non-religious — aren’t inter­ested in any­thing remotely the­o­log­i­cal, which means they end up believ­ing a lot of odds and ends of things they’ve heard (or thought they heard): vague impres­sions of Bible verses, bumper stick­ers, bon mots from the Matrix series, etc. etc. The rea­son this Oprah thing raises some hack­les is that it’s The­ol­ogy Light for the The­o­log­i­cally Chal­lenged and may reach peo­ple who didn’t want to go to all the bother of fig­ur­ing any­thing out.

    On the other hand, you’re prob­a­bly right that peo­ple prob­a­bly still won’t care overall.

  • Pen sub: I think it’s short for “penal substitution.”

  • My pas­tor shat­tered that with one pow­er­ful state­ment this week­end: GOD IS A LOVING EXPERIENCE!!! Remem­ber, God so LOVED the world. Greater LOVE has no man than this.… GOD IS A LOVING EXPERIENCE. Let’s not be fooled!

  • Wow, talk about wishy washy polit­cally cor­rect­ness. Regret­fully, Oprha Wine­fry would have been in the group back in the New Tes­ta­ment that would have wanted to have Jesus killed because He was mak­ing peo­ple feel bad for their sins.
    These new beleief well„simply put are evil. Plain and sim­ple. Scary stuff.

  • Scary is exactly what they are. I think prob­a­bly her whole series of pod­casts has come and gone at this point and hasn’t made a tremen­dous dif­fer­ence one way or the other (unless I’m miss­ing something).

    But peo­ple SHOULD have rejected it out­right. Even if the the­o­log­i­cal I.Q. in Amer­ica leaves some­thing to be desired, they should have made a stink about this.

    Oh well. I’ll just get myself worked up if I keep think­ing about it.

  • OPRAH … from spend­ing sev­eral years in Jere­miah Wright’s anti-American racist church, lis­ten­ing to ser­mons like “God Damn Amer­ica”, and giv­ing life time achieve­ment awards to the likes of Louis Far­rakhan … to her newest oppor­tunis­tic reli­gious beliefs … who could pos­si­bly take Oprah seri­ously? This woman’s ego is soooo big, being a bil­lion­aire celebrity isn’t enough, she has to start her own reli­gion … not to men­tion all the addi­tional money she is going to make sell­ing all those book, tapes, CD’s, etc. to her poor fol­low­ers. Oprah’s new power hun­gry ambi­tions include efforts to replace tra­di­tional Amer­ica with Obama … and access to a Pres­i­dent she puts into office … to her efforts at replac­ing Chris­tian­ity with a new reli­gion she con­trols. I think it’s time for Amer­ica to deny Oprah access to our tele­vi­sion sets.

  • I really had so much respect for Oprah but after this, i really dont respect her any­more. There’s only one true God and its def­i­nitely not Oprah. Repent Oprah or God’s judg­ment will come on you.

Leave a Reply

* Name, Email, and Comment are Required