Good King Wenceslas — Byz version

3 Responses and Counting...

  • bob 12.27.2010

    Inter­est­ing, but if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. The Ortho­dox sim­ply haven’t got any­thing as singable as these car­ols. If they did, some gung-ho con­vert would “trans­late” it into some­thing in ultra-King James Eng­lish that no one could under­stand. Luck­ily these escaped the treat­ment and can still be sung.

  • I agree — of my trio, this was the weakest.

    If you include West­ern Rite Ortho­dox, you can find hymns that are quite melodic. It’s not everyone’s taste, but I’ve heard some quite nice ones.

  • s-p

    I just like Tone 5, but Bob is right, it doesn’t make for a “West­ern sing along”. There’s only a hand­ful of Ortho­dox hymns that are singable that I’ve heard, even though they are beautiful.

Leave a Reply

* Name, Email, and Comment are Required